65-Year-Old Killingly Woman Accused in Canterbury Man’s Death

This blog post covers a tragic incident in Killingly, Connecticut. Police arrested a suspect after a fatal shooting earlier this week.

Details are still coming out from law enforcement and court documents. Folks across Windham County and beyond are following the case, waiting for answers as investigators dig deeper.

Find Your Ideal Getaway in Connecticut
Explore top-rated stays with no booking fees and instant confirmation. Your dream trip starts here!
Start Exploring Now

Fatal Shooting in Killingly Shakes Quiet Community

Police in Killingly responded late Monday night to a gunfire report at a home on Pratt Road. Officers found 39-year-old Andrew Michael Olson of Canterbury with a gunshot wound to his chest.

Paramedics rushed Olson to Day Kimball Hospital in Putnam. Sadly, he didn’t make it.

The suspect, 65-year-old Michelle Yeagher of 23 Pratt Road, was taken into custody on several felony charges. Police booked her for murder, carrying a dangerous weapon, risk of injury to a child, and first-degree reckless endangerment.

Charges and Arraignment

Yeagher appeared in Superior Court in Danielson the next day. Prosecutors asked for a $1 million bond, and the judge agreed.

Yeagher hasn’t entered a plea yet. Her next court date is set for December 11.

It’s still unclear what kind of relationship Yeagher and Olson had, if any. Authorities haven’t announced a motive, leaving the community anxious for more information.

Investigation Led by Eastern District Major Crime Squad

The Connecticut State Police Eastern District Major Crime Squad is leading the investigation. This unit often handles high-profile homicide cases in places like Norwich, Willimantic, and New London.

They’re now working to figure out what led up to Monday night’s deadly encounter.

Timeline of Events

According to reports:

At about 9:21 p.m., state police got a 911 call about a shooting at 23 Pratt Road in Killingly.
Troopers arrived and found Olson seriously wounded by a single gunshot.
Medical personnel took him to Day Kimball Hospital, where he was declared deceased.
Police detained Yeagher at the scene and charged her.
Investigators are now combing the crime scene for evidence.

Impact on the Community

This shooting has rattled Killingly, Canterbury, and nearby towns like Plainfield and Griswold. Violent crime is pretty rare in this corner of northeastern Connecticut, so people are shocked and unsettled.

Regional Concerns

Community leaders and law enforcement are asking residents to stay patient while the investigation continues. In Windham, officials have made similar requests before, reminding everyone that facts matter more than rumors.

Local advocacy groups are talking about domestic violence, gun ownership, and ways to prevent crime. Even without all the details, many see this as a reminder of why mental health support, conflict resolution, and community watch programs matter in Connecticut towns.

Next Steps in the Legal Process

With Yeagher’s case moving through the courts, attention is turning to the December 11 hearing in Danielson. That date might finally bring some answers as prosecutors share initial findings and the defense starts to lay out its side.

Cases like this usually go through several stages—arraignment, pretrial motions, and maybe a trial in superior court. People from Killingly to Mansfield will be watching, hoping the truth comes out.

Awaiting Answers

Lots of questions hang in the air as the investigation moves forward. What actually sparked the confrontation?

Was this the first sign of trouble at the Pratt Road home, or had things happened before? And what’s going to happen with the charges against Yeagher once the case hits court?

Right now, the Eastern District Major Crime Squad and State Police are still out there. They’re gathering evidence, talking to witnesses, and trying to piece together what really unfolded Monday night.

It’s a heavy reminder: even quiet Connecticut towns like Killingly and Griswold aren’t immune to violence. One night can change everything for a whole community.

Here is the source article for this story: Killingly Woman, 65, Accused Of Killing Canterbury Man: Police

Discover Your Perfect Stay in Connecticut
Find available hotels and vacation homes instantly. No fees, best rates guaranteed!
Check Availability Now