Connecticut Sea Captain’s Home, Former Button Factory, Now For Sale

This article takes a closer look at a truly special property in East Hampton, Connecticut—a sea captain’s home from 1780 that’s been turned into a luxury residence. We’ll dig into its rich history, its quirky architectural details, and the modern touches that make it one of the most eye-catching homes on the market in Middlesex County.

A 1780 Sea Captain’s Home in the Heart of Middle Haddam

You’ll find this historic house at 58 Middle Haddam Road in East Hampton. Sea captain Elijah Johnson had it built back in 1780.

Find Your Ideal Getaway in Connecticut
Explore top-rated stays with no booking fees and instant confirmation. Your dream trip starts here!
Start Exploring Now

The home sits in the charming village of Middle Haddam and really shows off the area’s maritime roots. There’s a certain draw here that brings in buyers from all over Connecticut—Hartford, New Haven, and even those smaller river towns like Essex and Old Saybrook.

It’s listed on the National Register of Historic Places, which points to its architectural and cultural value. In a real estate world where homes with character are getting harder to find, this one stands out as a lovingly preserved slice of 18th-century New England.

From Working Property to Refined Residence

This home’s had more than one chapter. Beyond just being a private residence, it once held a foundry that made buttons during the Civil War.

That bit of industrial past sets it apart from other historic homes in places like Middletown, Glastonbury, and Manchester, where most houses stayed strictly domestic.

Historic Character Paired With Modern Comfort

Buyers from West Hartford, Simsbury, and New London want it all these days—genuine historic charm, but with the comforts of a modern layout. This Middle Haddam property really nails that balance.

The home sits on about 0.7 acres, which feels just right—not too much to handle, but enough space to enjoy. There’s even a private brook and a little waterfall winding through the yard. That water feature is pretty rare, even for these scenic river towns, and it adds a sense of calm and privacy that’s tough to find.

Original Features Carefully Preserved

Inside, the owners and restorers managed to keep what matters most. They held onto and restored the original features but still made the place livable for today.

Original oak paneling that shows off late 18th-century craftsmanship
Several fireplaces that work as both historic focal points and cozy spots to gather
Period-appropriate details that keep the look consistent throughout

These touches give the home the authenticity that history buffs all over Connecticut—from Bridgeport to Danbury—are always searching for.

Layout Designed for Today’s Lifestyle

The house keeps its historic exterior and key interior features, but the layout and amenities have been updated for modern life. That mix is especially attractive to folks moving within the state, whether they’re coming from busy places like Stamford or quieter towns like Colchester.

With five bedrooms and two bathrooms, there’s plenty of space for a bigger household, guests, or even a few home offices and hobby rooms.

First-Floor Primary Suite and Country Kitchen

One feature that really stands out is the primary bedroom on the first floor. That’s pretty rare in a house this old, and it’s something a lot of buyers want. The primary suite even has its own fireplace, so you get comfort and that classic historic vibe all at once.

The eat-in country kitchen feels warm and traditional, but it’s been updated for modern use. The kitchen’s layout works for everyday living, easy entertaining, and the kind of relaxed vibe that’s become even more important as more people work from home.

Modern Updates and Market Position

The home’s gotten some serious modern updates alongside all the preserved history. Two new bathrooms and a better interior flow bring it in line with what buyers expect today, but the house still keeps its character.

It’s listed at $689,000, which puts it right in the mix for luxury historic homes in Central Connecticut. For buyers comparing spots in East Hampton and nearby towns along the Connecticut River, this place’s mix of history, land, and updates really makes it stand out.

Representation and Next Steps for Buyers

Teri Lewis of William Pitt Julia B. Fee Sotheby’s International Realty represents the listing. This brokerage has a reputation for handling distinctive, historic properties across the region.

If you love authentic New England history but also want modern comfort, 58 Middle Haddam Road might just be what you’re looking for. In Connecticut, historic homes are cherished and honestly, finding one that’s move-in-ready isn’t easy.

This East Hampton property has been carefully preserved and thoughtfully updated. It’s a genuine piece of Connecticut’s past, ready for its next chapter.

Here is the source article for this story: CT home was built for sea captain and produced buttons. Now it’s a luxury home up for sale

Discover Your Perfect Stay in Connecticut
Find available hotels and vacation homes instantly. No fees, best rates guaranteed!
Check Availability Now